2017
| Kurt Walding | Arizona State | NCAA D-I |
| Noah Banks | Florida | NCAA D-I |
| Nick Anderson | Iowa | NCAA D-I |
| Colton Dinsdale | Iowa | NCAA D-I |
| Daviyon Nixon | Iowa | NCAA D-I |
| Mekhi Sargent | Iowa | NCAA D-I |
| Josh Knipfel | Iowa State | NCAA D-I |
| Logan Busch | South Dakota State | NCAA D-I |
| Alex Parella | South Dakota State | NCAA D-I |
| Elijah Swehla | Southeast Missouri State | NCAA D-I |
| Ky'el Hemby | Southern Mississippi | NCAA D-I |
| Vincent Perry | Tennessee State | NCAA D-I |
| Anthony McKinney | Texas Christian | NCAA D-I |
| Kai Locksley | Texas at El-Paso | NCAA D-I |
2016
| Terrell Collins | Arkansas | D-I NCAA |
| Kadeem Goulbourne | Austin Peay | D-I NCAA |
| Blake Yager | Cincinnati | D-I NCAA |
| Shaq Jones | Eastern Michigan | D-I NCAA |
| D'Anfernee McGriff | Florida Atlantic | D-I NCAA |
| Kevin Kwapis | Georgia State | D-I NCAA |
| Nick Easley | Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Josh Knipfel | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Andre Nunez | Louisiana Lafayette | D-I NCAA |
| Royal Silver | Minnesota | D-I NCAA |
| Connor Novak-Goar | Minnesota | D-I NCAA |
| Mykelti Williams | Northern Illinois | D-I NCAA |
| Tobias Moss | South Alabama | D-I NCAA |
| Austin Ahrendt | Texas Christian | D-I NCAA |
| Ish Seisay | Virginia Tech | D-I NCAA |
| AJ Bush | Virginia Tech | D-I NCAA |
| Hakeem Bailey | West Virginia | D-I NCAA |
| Andrew Van Ginkel | Wisconsin | D-I NCAA |
| Jalen Dingle | Kentucky State | D-II NCAA |
| Michael Smith | Missouri Western | D-II NCAA |
| Daniel Ezeagwu | Tarleton State | D-II NCAA |
| Bobby Patterson | Winona State | D-II NCAA |
| Brady Smith | Graceland | NAIA |
| Russell Jones | Grand View | NAIA |
| Jett Kettwick | Grand View | NAIA |
| Brock Larsen | Midland | NAIA |
2015
| DA Williams | Alabama Birmingham | D-I NCAA |
| Darez Diggs | Alabama Birmingham | D-I NCAA |
| Stacy Keely | Alabama Birmingham | D-I NCAA |
| Malique Johnson | Alabama Birmingham | D-I NCAA |
| John Swisher | Ball State | D-I NCAA |
| Anthony Johnson | Buffalo | D-I NCAA |
| Na'Ty Rodgers | Houston | D-I NCAA |
| Jayme Thompson | Indiana | D-I NCAA |
| Dom Dafney | Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Sam Harms | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Tyus Mason | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Anthony Anderson | Marshall | D-I NCAA |
| Merrick Jackson | Minnesota | D-I NCAA |
| Alton Meeks | Northern Illinois | D-I NCAA |
| Detric Bing-Dukes | Ole Miss | D-I NCAA |
| Abe Freeman | Southeast Louisiana | D-I NCAA |
| Taj Williams | Texas Christian | D-I NCAA |
| Rico Gafford | Wyoming | D-I NCAA |
| Mark Hall | Wyoming | D-I NCAA |
| Thomas Marquez | Grambling State | D-IAA NCAA |
| Stone Kane | Northern Colorado | D-IAA NCAA |
| Ben Garlock | South Dakota | D-IAA NCAA |
| Kane Barker | Central Missouri State | D-II NCAA |
| Tre Williams-Brown | Findlay | D-II NCAA |
| Adonis Davis | Florida Tech | D-II NCAA |
| Antonio Davis | Lindenwood | D-II NCAA |
| Max Stewart | MN State Mankato | D-II NCAA |
| Jake Porter | MN State Mankato | D-II NCAA |
| Jimmy Hawk | Nebraska Kearney | D-II NCAA |
| Turner Gaines | Nebraska Kearney | D-II NCAA |
| Ben Spaeth | Northwest Missouri State | D-II NCAA |
| Marshall Clark | Northwest Missouri State | D-II NCAA |
| Zach Martin | Northwest Missouri State | D-II NCAA |
| Keith Schwickerath | Upper Iowa | D-II NCAA |
| Mitch Stopko | Coe College | D-III NCAA |
| Alex Middleton | Graceland | NAIA |
| Ryan Campbell | Robert Morris | NAIA |
2014
| Xavier Quigley | Akron | D-I NCAA |
| Mondo Williams | Appalachian State | D-I NCAA |
| Trey Bowman | Buffalo | D-I NCAA |
| Darius Commissiong | East Carolina | D-I NCAA |
| Anthony Brown | Eastern Michigan | D-I NCAA |
| Kelvin Rainey | Georgia State | D-I NCAA |
| James Works | Houston | D-I NCAA |
| Andrew Davis | Illinois | D-I NCAA |
| Ronald Nash | Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Luke Schultheiss | Louisville | D-I NCAA |
| Paul Harris | Louisville | D-I NCAA |
| Mike Edwards | Memphis | D-I NCAA |
| Charlie Rogers | Minnesota | D-I NCAA |
| Ford Howell | North Carolina State | D-I NCAA |
| Kevin Robbins | Ohio | D-I NCAA |
| Alex Langer | Wyoming | D-I NCAA |
| Bryson McCabe | Montana State | D-IAA NCAA |
| Tyler Brooks | North Carolina Central | D-IAA NCAA |
| Alex Reed | North Dakota | D-IAA NCAA |
| Reid Bonner | Northern Iowa | D-IAA NCAA |
| Chris Schleuger | Northern Iowa | D-IAA NCAA |
| Marcus Montgomery | Northern Iowa | D-IAA NCAA |
| Tay Bender | Southeast Missouri State | D-IAA NCAA |
| Justin Vanhoutan | Bemidji State | D-II NCAA |
| Aaron VanDyk | Southwest MN State | D-II NCAA |
| Mikeel Stewart | Washburn | D-II NCAA |
| Zac Gillis | Washburn | D-II NCAA |
| Devon Paye | West Texas A&M | D-II NCAA |
| Cooper Kanne | Central | D-III NCAA |
| Collin Werkman | Platteville | D-III NCAA |
| Bryce Lidtka | Dordt | NAIA |
| Jacob Shoultz | Grandview | NAIA |
| JD Culjat | Morningside | NAIA |
| Thomas Reece | Morningside | NAIA |
2013
| Sebastian Tretola | Arkansas | D-I NCAA |
| Marcus Caffey | Georgia State | D-I NCAA |
| Kato Fawkes | Idaho | D-I NCAA |
| Max Martial | Idaho | D-I NCAA |
| Geronimo Allison | Illinois | D-I NCAA |
| DeAndre Herron | Indiana | D-I NCAA |
| Larry Mazyck | Kansas | D-I NCAA |
| Trevon Young | Louisville | D-I NCAA |
| DaShaughn Terry | Memphis | D-I NCAA |
| Cody Poock | Minnesota | D-I NCAA |
| Ryan Langford | New Mexico | D-I NCAA |
| Daniel Henry | New Mexico | D-I NCAA |
| Jamie Byrd | South Florida | D-I NCAA |
| Connor Bravard | Troy | D-I NCAA |
| Chris Tyler | South Dakota | D-IAA NCAA |
| Travis Zimmerman | South Dakota State | D-IAA NCAA |
| Landon Schultz | South Dakota State | D-IAA NCAA |
| Ashton Henderson | Southeastern Louisiana State | D-IAA NCAA |
| Dijon Starr | Concordia St. Paul | D-II NCAA |
| Eddie Vinson | Emporia State | D-II NCAA |
| Brandon Allen | Emporia State | D-II NCAA |
| DeVante Snyder | Ferris State | D-II NCAA |
| George Sehl | Northwest Missouri State | D-II NCAA |
| William Wright | Seton Hill | D-II NCAA |
| Marco Naughton | Sioux Falls | D-II NCAA |
| Brock Hinkel | Valdosta State | D-II NCAA |
| Max Mattias | Coe College | D-III NCAA |
| Bryant Johnson | Grandview | NAIA |
2012
| Dallas Hinkhouse | Illinois | D-I NCAA |
| Martize Barr | Illinois | D-I NCAA |
| Jordan Heiderman | Indiana | D-I NCAA |
| Steven Funderburk | Indiana | D-I NCAA |
| Andrew Stone | Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Aaron Wimberly | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Tysen Streeter | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Tyler Harmeyer | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Rodney Coe | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Rob Myers | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Isaiah Johnson | Kansas | D-I NCAA |
| Mike Smithburg | Kansas | D-I NCAA |
| Jake Waters | Kansas State | D-I NCAA |
| Devon Nash | Kansas State | D-I NCAA |
| Travis Green | Kansas State | D-I NCAA |
| Deon Long | Maryland | D-I NCAA |
| Don Jackson | Nevada | D-I NCAA |
| Paul Brown | South Florida | D-I NCAA |
| Vernard Roberts | Southern Miss | D-I NCAA |
| Austin Stephens | Utah State | D-I NCAA |
| Malkaam Muhammad | Wyoming | D-I NCAA |
| Antonio Armstrong | Northern Iowa | D-IAA NCAA |
| Ellis Jordan | Northern Iowa | D-IAA NCAA |
| Terrell Porter | Ferris State | D-II NCAA |
| Rashaad Dunnagin | Ft. Hays St. | D-II NCAA |
| Gunner Gilland | Buena Vista | D-III NCAA |
| Spencer Scar | Simpson College | D-III NCAA |
| Chase Kleopfer | Wartburg | D-III NCAA |
| Cameron Biondi | Wartburg | D-III NCAA |
| Carr Terpstra | Wisconsin Platteville | D-III NCAA |
| Michael Freeman | Bethel College | NAIA |
| Tyler Ahrens | Grandview | NAIA |
| Devin Thomas | Morningside | NAIA |
2011
| Cody Dickson | Ball State | D-I NCAA |
| Sean Skradis | Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Eric Simmons | Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Drake Ferch | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Cory Morrissey | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Ryan Hubbell | Louisville | D-I NCAA |
| Ricardo Young | Maryland | D-I NCAA |
| Alfred Sharp | New Mexico State | D-I NCAA |
| DQ Johnson | North Texas | D-I NCAA |
| Ty Branz | Ohio | D-I NCAA |
| Matt Waters | Ohio | D-I NCAA |
| Stetzon Bair | Oregon | D-I NCAA |
| Evan Williams | Northern Iowa | D-IAA NCAA |
| Jalen Barnes | Northern Iowa | D-IAA NCAA |
| Wes Smith | Northern Iowa | D-IAA NCAA |
| Austin Knowlton | South Dakota State | D-IAA NCAA |
| Andrew Brown | South Dakota State | D-IAA NCAA |
| Tyler Bos | Minnesota - Crookston | D-II NCAA |
| Cole Jackson | Minnesota - Crookston | D-II NCAA |
| Quinten Hall | Grandview | NAIA |
| Nolan Long | Morningside | NAIA |
2010
| Dan Heiar | Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Zack Stoudt | Ole Miss | D-I NCAA |
| Jared Ebert | Oregon | D-I NCAA |
| Dallas Hendrikson | Rutgers | D-I NCAA |
| Max Miller | San Jose State | D-I NCAA |
| David Whitmore | Troy | D-I NCAA |
| Lenard Williams | Washington State | D-I NCAA |
| Shaq Rowell | West Virginia | D-I NCAA |
| Bo Adams | Augustana | D-II NCAA |
| Keaton Tuttle | Fort Hays State | D-II NCAA |
| Eli Cordon | Fort Hays State | D-II NCAA |
| Austin Nichols | Southwest Minnesota State | D-II NCAA |
| Abe Kos | Southwest Minnesota State | D-II NCAA |
| Shane Prater | Texas A&M Kingsville | D-II NCAA |
| Anthony Church | Upper Iowa | D-II NCAA |
| Jeff Grell | Wayne State | D-II NCAA |
| Jordan Roberts-Lewis | Grand View | NAIA |
| Lorenzo Dennard | Missouri Valley | NAIA |
2009
| Joe Audlehelm | Iowa | D-I NCAA |
| Austin McBeth | Iowa State | D-I NCAA |
| Kevis Streeter | Lousiana-Layfayette | D-I NCAA |
| Mike Henry | Minnesota | D-I NCAA |
| David Blackwell | Bethune Cookman | D-IAA NCAA |
| Matt Thayer | Missouri State | D-IAA NCAA |
| James Caine | Missouri State | D-IAA NCAA |
| Jessy McMullin | Southern Illinois | D-IAA NCAA |
| Paul Hughes | Central Missouri | D-II NCAA |
| Marcus Sullivan | Southwest Baptist | D-II NCAA |
| Jayveri Kelly | Washburn | D-II NCAA |
| John O'Malley | Whittier | D-III NCAA |
| Tony Bland | Peru State | NAIA |
| Jacob Grobe | Peru State | NAIA |
| Ryan Bradley | St. Ambrose | NAIA |